Our Staff

Profile image of Andrew Isenhower

Andrew Isenhower



Our Pastor is the Reverand Andrew W. Isenhower. Andrew comes to Good Shepherd from St. Luke Lutheran Church in the Olympia neighborhood of Columbia, SC. He received his Master of Divinity in 2011 from Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary in Columbia. Prior to that, he earned an AA in Religious Studies from Spartanburg College in 2005 and a BA in Religion from Newberry College in 2007. He was born and raised in Spartanburg, SC. He is joined by his wife, Michelle, and two children, James and Amelia.

Isenhower is passionate about preaching and teaching, with a special interest in helping God's people connect scripture, worship, and the teachings of the faith with their daily lives. Pastor Andrew loves spending time with family, traveling and taking road trips, and attending the occasional sporting event. He is an avid guitarist and enjoys a wide range of musical styles and genres.


Profile image of Deborah Mitchell

Deborah Mitchell

Parish Administrator

Office: 803-787-4413

Deborah Mitchell started serving Good Shepherd as the Parish Administrator in December 2018. She was born and raised here in the Columbia area. Deborah enjoys making cards and scrapbooking with friends. She and her family currently live in Irmo.  They attend church at Palmetto Church of Christ on Nursery Road in Irmo, South Carolina. If you are interested in helping in the church office by answering phones, stuffing envelopes, or cutting inserts, contact Deborah in the office.


Profile image of Susan Sturkie

Susan Sturkie



Susan Sturkie has been Organist at Good Shepherd since October 1988. Born in Mooresville, NC, Susan graduated from St. Andrews Presbyterian College (now St. Andrews University) in Laurinburg, NC, with a B.M. in Music Education studying both organ and voice. After graduating, she taught elementary school music at Ft. Bragg and Ft. Jackson Dependents Schools. She is a member of the American Guild of Organists, the Association of Lutheran Church Musicians, and the Association of Lutheran Musicians of SC. Susan serves as Membership Chair of the Greater Columbia chapter of the American Guild of Organists and Treasurer of the Association of Lutheran Musicians of SC. Susan and her husband Dick are the parents of one son, Trey.


Profile image of Joey Allison

Joey Allison



Joey Allison has served as Sexton at Good Shepherd since January 1993. Over the years he has had to adjust to many changes, including new pastors, new staff, new council members, the Day School, and building changes. Joey takes care of the physical facilities as well as the church campus grounds. He is always looking for help out in the yard! In his spare time Joey enjoys disc golf, vegetable gardening, canning (he even has a small greenhouse in his backyard), music, watercolor painting, writing, and collecting all sorts of old stuff.